2020-06-23

Reverse NILs in CQ WW: 2011

The basic notion of reverse NILs (rNILs; or, I suppose, RNILs) is described here, along with a description of a simple script for calculating rNILs for CQ WW contests and the result of applying that code to the contests for 2005. See also the comments at the end of that post.

Here are the results for 2011:

2011 SSB:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
OG5B 1172 1171
VA3SWG 1157 945
SI9AM 2373 822
ZW8T 1985 682
LY1G 664 659
R3ZV 736 652
UN7BEW 667 635
PY2NY 1181 626
JK1OPL 760 564
R7AW 749 547


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
OG5B 1172 1171 99.9
LY1G 664 659 99.2
ZP6DYA 132 131 99.2
N3UA 359 356 99.2
NY4S 105 104 99.0
F4CGJ 96 95 99.0
F4FYG 91 90 98.9
K4CEB 159 156 98.1
JE1GZB 283 274 96.8
EE5W 149 143 96.0


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
NR5M 136 60
N9RV 123 49
N7DD 67 42
AA4V/VP9 1956 38
KU1CW 61 33
W0AIH 196 32
KV0Q 53 31
W3LPL 275 15
K7ZSD 123 13
NK7U 314 12


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N7DD 67 42 62.7
KV0Q 53 31 58.5
KU1CW 61 33 54.1
NR5M 136 60 44.1
N9RV 123 49 39.8
WN9O 36 8 22.2
N3RS 36 7 19.4
W0AIH 196 32 16.3
KI7M 38 6 15.8
W7IJ 27 4 14.8

2011 CW:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
UA1CEC 1168 1157
RA3ATE 908 903
YB4IR 913 894
YL2SW 838 836
UA4CNZ 565 561
RM2T 533 532
I1XSG 533 527
OH2LU 737 413
JR4GPA 930 372
VE1DX 782 366


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
RM2T 533 532 99.8
YL2SW 838 836 99.8
UA3TJF 308 307 99.7
UT5DJ 265 264 99.6
RA3ATE 908 903 99.4
UA4CNZ 565 561 99.3
N6NF 137 136 99.3
DL5SVB 131 130 99.2
RK4S 124 123 99.2
UA1CEC 1168 1157 99.1


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
NR5M 316 59
N9RV 78 51
N0NI 91 42
K0RF 237 10
NR4M 147 9
KC1XX 260 8
K5GO 91 8
W2PV 132 8
K3LR 220 7
N5FO 45 7


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N9RV 78 51 65.4
N0NI 91 42 46.2
NR5M 316 59 18.7
N5FO 45 7 15.6
W1WEF 26 4 15.4
NS2X 38 5 13.2
N3CZ 39 5 12.8
AA1K 30 3 10.0
W7VJ 62 6 9.7
N0IJ 33 3 9.1

Arguably no major anomalies there, although, depending on the resources available to the CQ WW Contest Committee, a closer inspection of some of the logs placed highly in the fourth and eighth tables might have been warranted (maybe such inspection took place; I have no way of knowing).

2020-06-21

Reverse NILs in CQ WW: 2010

The basic notion of reverse NILs (rNILs; or, I suppose, RNILs) is described here, along with a description of a simple script for calculating rNILs for CQ WW contests and the result of applying that code to the contests for 2005. See also the comments at the end of that post.

Here are the results for 2010:

2010 SSB:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
JT5DX 1407 1388
ZY6Z 1510 783
OR0A 812 767
GI5K 1219 591
IR1I 578 575
VA2TG 1136 478
W1MAW 476 472
K4JLD 450 447
5N7M 1002 446
F8ARK 1472 401


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
EA1TI 359 358 99.7
IR1I 578 575 99.5
K4JLD 450 447 99.3
W1MAW 476 472 99.2
EE5W 197 195 99.0
PV8DR 164 162 98.8
JT5DX 1407 1388 98.6
WB0YLE 68 67 98.5
UT5ULX 190 187 98.4
HI3EPR 189 186 98.4


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
AC5O 45 41
W5RI 36 35
K1RX 158 30
NR5M 108 24
AK8E 40 24
K3LR 343 18
NN2W 34 18
N5MV 31 17
N7DD 48 17
K2Z 46 16


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
W5RI 36 35 97.2
AC5O 45 41 91.1
AK8E 40 24 60.0
N5MV 31 17 54.8
NN2W 34 18 52.9
N5ZK 28 14 50.0
N7DD 48 17 35.4
K2Z 46 16 34.8
NR5M 108 24 22.2
WG3J 73 14 19.2

2010 CW:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
RW9JD 883 880
IK6MNB 1184 606
MI0BPB 591 579
YO4BEW 531 529
OK1KZ 581 513
OM5UM 485 483
KH6MB 1517 477
TM0T 552 470
YN4SU 1337 454
CO8LY 1818 448


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
RW9JD 883 880 99.7
YO4BEW 531 529 99.6
OM5UM 485 483 99.6
OM4AY 159 158 99.4
RV9YZ 148 147 99.3
SM0Q 431 427 99.1
7K4VPV 93 92 98.9
UT5PQ 177 175 98.9
DL8DXL 156 153 98.1
MI0BPB 591 579 98.0


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
WV6E 55 51
NR5M 296 15
KC1XX 260 13
K0RF 172 10
W1WEF 33 9
NQ4I 199 7
N4WW 86 7
W0AIH 155 7
W2FU 132 6
W3LPL 168 5


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
WV6E 55 51 92.7
W1WEF 33 9 27.3
WJ9B 26 5 19.2
K8PO 31 4 12.9
W5RU 33 4 12.1
KT3Y 31 3 9.7
N7TT 33 3 9.1
W6JZH 35 3 8.6
W9SN 48 4 8.3
N4WW 86 7 8.1

W5RI and AC5O's SSB logs and WV6E's CW log are (obviously) anomalous and might have repaid inspection.

2020-06-20

Reverse NILs in CQ WW: 2009

The basic notion of reverse NILs (rNILs; or, I suppose, RNILs) is described here, along with a description of a simple script for calculating rNILs for CQ WW contests and the result of applying that code to the contests for 2005. See also the comments at the end of that post.

Here are the results for 2009:

2009 SSB:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
3W1M 1338 986
A41MX 822 814
A47RS 1639 784
HK3JJH 733 661
LU2QC 1110 645
IR6D 633 597
S57RTH 1015 551
DJ0AH 531 526
PI4COM 2775 519
EA3RCB 495 489


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
N2ED 366 365 99.7
CX5TR 308 307 99.7
UT5ID 475 473 99.6
PY3PA 231 230 99.6
9A7YY 185 184 99.5
LY2OM 365 363 99.5
UX2MK 163 162 99.4
EA9BO 158 157 99.4
EA1GAZ 145 144 99.3
IZ0BVU 232 230 99.1


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
NR5M 439 45
N5DX 142 30
AA4V/VP9 1256 19
K3LR 308 17
K7ZSD 113 17
N0NI 65 16
W3TB/VP9 730 15
K1TTT 250 12
W3LPL 226 12
N7BT 43 12


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N2RRA 27 8 29.6
W8BI 28 8 28.6
N7BT 43 12 27.9
N0NI 65 16 24.6
N5DX 142 30 21.1
W0UA 49 9 18.4
K7ZSD 113 17 15.0
N6AQ 31 4 12.9
K9LA 25 3 12.0
WB9Z 44 5 11.4

2009 CW:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
VU2PAI 1469 1452
IT9INO 1133 1099
ON4IA 814 768
HC2SL 1042 569
SJ2W 2638 455
RV9CP 620 439
KE2WY 477 431
EA1FBU 430 428
OK1KZ 502 402
TA2KK 848 313


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
EA1FBU 430 428 99.5
W2TB 158 157 99.4
VK4TI 106 105 99.1
PU5AAD 97 96 99.0
DL1HSI 97 96 99.0
VU2PAI 1469 1452 98.8
DL8TG 86 85 98.8
F6KMX 53 52 98.1
RW6BD 134 131 97.8
IT9INO 1133 1099 97.0


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
NR5M 429 40
KV0Q 39 38
K0RF 300 27
NQ4I 319 19
K1LZ 197 18
N7DD 104 14
K1TTT 249 13
WR7Q 74 13
K5GO 200 10
K3LR 343 10


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
KV0Q 39 38 97.4
W1PID 28 6 21.4
WN9O 35 7 20.0
WR7Q 74 13 17.6
K9RS 53 9 17.0
WB9Z 37 6 16.2
K5MR 62 10 16.1
K3ZM 47 7 14.9
W5VX 42 6 14.3
N7DD 104 14 13.5

KV0Q's CW (single-band) log stands out as being anomalous. I have seen no evidence that he was invited to provide an explanation for its lack of recorded W QSOs.

2020-06-19

Reverse NILs in CQ WW: 2008

The basic notion of reverse NILs (rNILs; or, I suppose, RNILs) is described here, along with a description of a simple script for calculating rNILs for CQ WW contests and the result of applying that code to the contests for 2005. See also the comments at the end of that post.

Here are the results for 2008:

2008 SSB:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
EW8KY 1522 859
WC2L 807 805
W1DX 1344 646
YY1MTX 593 587
FM5AN 721 515
RZ1ZZ 1119 457
S57RTH 879 416
VE3JAQ 693 405
VA3YP 840 396
ZV2K 570 391


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
WC2L 807 805 99.8
VU2SWS 376 375 99.7
F4FHI 226 225 99.6
PP5TR 199 198 99.5
WA3RHW 138 137 99.3
N3UA 99 98 99.0
YY1MTX 593 587 99.0
F4CGJ 94 93 98.9
EA4LU 271 268 98.9
EA6UP 179 177 98.9


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
NR5M 233 73
N7DD 75 46
K7ZSD 119 39
N0NI 75 28
KI7M 49 23
W1DX 47 19
N2IC 82 18
N4T 176 15
K9RS 56 13
K3LR 241 12


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N7DD 75 46 61.3
KI7M 49 23 46.9
W1DX 47 19 40.4
N0NI 75 28 37.3
K7ZSD 119 39 32.8
NR5M 233 73 31.3
K9RS 56 13 23.2
N2IC 82 18 22.0
W7WA 31 6 19.4
K7DSL 28 5 17.9

2008 CW:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
VU2PAI 661 653
Z33A 743 579
RV9MZ 530 529
IS0HQJ 474 437
JE1ZWT 778 430
OK1KZ 424 362
S57Z 1308 327
K9CJ 309 301
7X0RY 1299 282
RN4LL 280 279


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
RV9MZ 530 529 99.8
RN4LL 280 279 99.6
RZ0SO 256 255 99.6
KP2BH 207 206 99.5
SN3A 122 121 99.2
VU2PAI 661 653 98.8
K9CJ 309 301 97.4
SM0KV 62 60 96.8
N8NOE 140 133 95.0
KI4TZ 130 123 94.6


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
NR5M 241 41
N7UA 86 27
N0NI 79 24
N8NOE 26 23
KV0Q 30 20
NQ4I 209 16
K1TTT 143 12
K3LR 205 11
K9RS 42 11
W3LPL 175 9


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N8NOE 26 23 88.5
KV0Q 30 20 66.7
N7UA 86 27 31.4
N0NI 79 24 30.4
K9RS 42 11 26.2
W2FU 36 7 19.4
NR5M 241 41 17.0
K3ZM 40 6 15.0
K1KI 39 5 12.8
K6XX 27 3 11.1

By now the pattern is obvious: if the first one or two entries in the fourth column of the fourth or eighth table are noticeably higher than the values on lower rows, it might have been a good idea for the CQ WW Contest Committee to have examined the relevant logs to make sure that everything was in order and that there was no unsportsmanlike conduct taking place in the form of logs missing QSOs that had in fact taken place, and therefore penalising other stations by causing them to record NILs.

The first few entries in the second and sixth tables should probably also have been examined, to try to understand why the values in the fourth column were so high -- almost always these seem to be due to obvious logging errors, though.

2020-06-18

CQ WPX SSB logs for 2020

CQ WPX SSB logs for 2020 have been added to this repository of public CQ WPX logs.

Reverse NILs in CQ WW: 2007

The basic notion of reverse NILs (rNILs; or, I suppose, RNILs) is described here, along with a description of a simple script for calculating rNILs for CQ WW contests and the result of applying that code to the contests for 2005. See also the comments at the end of that post.

Here are the results for 2007:

2007 SSB:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
OT5L 2560 2516
ER5GB 815 814
SN1I 951 625
T99W 1571 578
LZ1ND 482 481
6Y1V 5555 450
EA1ET 853 433
OK1KZ 524 432
YV4A 3003 420
PY2AA 892 418


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
ER5GB 815 814 99.9
LZ1ND 482 481 99.8
PY2TW 139 138 99.3
F4EWU 231 229 99.1
DJ6XV 105 104 99.0
OK1JN 92 91 98.9
AG9D 84 83 98.8
IQ3EZ 82 81 98.8
VU2SWS 315 311 98.7
IT9YVO 312 308 98.7


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
N7DD 91 81
K7ZSD 79 34
N2IC 92 31
K3LR 352 28
KU1CW 35 17
K1TTT 243 14
W0AIH 77 13
W3PP 52 11
W4WS 43 11
NQ4I 190 11


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N7DD 91 81 89.0
KU1CW 35 17 48.6
K7ZSD 79 34 43.0
W0YR 25 9 36.0
N2IC 92 31 33.7
K1VU 32 10 31.2
W4WS 43 11 25.6
W3PP 52 11 21.2
W0AIH 77 13 16.9
W7WA 36 5 13.9

2007 CW:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
LT1F 4304 4291
SV1ENG 1632 1561
IH9U 879 826
OK1FZM 575 571
OK1KZ 481 365
UA9OW 344 343
DK3GI 1606 300
UX2MF 369 298
S56A 613 291
YO2LEA 289 288


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
UA9OW 344 343 99.7
LT1F 4304 4291 99.7
YO2LEA 289 288 99.7
9G5ZS 198 197 99.5
W9/DM5TI 153 152 99.3
OK1FZM 575 571 99.3
SM0KV 102 101 99.0
DL1EHR 193 191 99.0
DJ2SX 112 109 97.3
SV1ENG 1632 1561 95.6


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
K0RF 169 63
W9/DM5TI 47 46
N7UA 25 18
K0XTR 25 15
N3RS 111 14
K5GO 193 14
N6RO 432 12
K1TTT 169 12
NQ4I 192 10
K3LR 177 8


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
W9/DM5TI 47 46 97.9
N7UA 25 18 72.0
K0XTR 25 15 60.0
K0RF 169 63 37.3
N4CJ 25 5 20.0
N7TT 30 5 16.7
W3UA 25 4 16.0
K6OY 26 4 15.4
K1LZ 34 5 14.7
K1RX 49 7 14.3

As in 2006, N7DD's SSB log might have been worthy of a closer look. As far as I know it wasn't called out for examination, but the deliberations of the CQ WW Contest Committee are -- probably on purpose -- shrouded in mystery, so it's impossible to know what investigations, if any, they undertook to understand the cause of statistical anomalies in the various calculations that they (I assume) performed against the logs.

2020-06-17

Reverse NILs in CQ WW: 2006

The basic notion of reverse NILs (rNILs; or, I suppose, RNILs) is described here, along with a description of a simple script for calculating rNILs for CQ WW contests and the result of applying that code to the contests for 2005. See also the comments at the end of that post.

Here are the results for 2006:

2006 SSB:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
IZ8EPX 1348 1345
F5BBD 1025 925
RW3WWW 1798 813
PY5DC 777 765
9Y4NZ 1520 734
EI9E 1881 730
PI4ZI 724 721
OA4WW 2841 668
VP2MDY 1866 656
YU1HFG 658 650


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
IZ8EPX 1348 1345 99.8
N3BNA 347 346 99.7
I8TWB 272 271 99.6
PI4ZI 724 721 99.6
LA2OKA 220 219 99.5
EX7ML 162 161 99.4
IT9YVO 304 302 99.3
IW2MWZ 132 131 99.2
PY3DX 230 228 99.1
PY6KY 107 106 99.1


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
N7DD 84 77
N2IC 82 30
W3LPL 187 30
KV0Q 57 25
K3LR 274 21
NQ4I 309 20
W7WA 52 19
K6OP 32 16
KC1XX 165 13
NK7U 170 12


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N7DD 84 77 91.7
K6OP 32 16 50.0
KV0Q 57 25 43.9
N2IC 82 30 36.6
W7WA 52 19 36.5
NE3F 48 11 22.9
K1IR 30 6 20.0
W3BGN 30 6 20.0
N2MM 41 8 19.5
W2CG 28 5 17.9

2006 CW:

Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs
RU9UZM 1384 1245
HK1AR 1192 1101
RN4AT 806 794
YO7BGA 762 746
EA8NN 888 686
WX4G 1085 640
S51Z 1303 620
PA3ADJ 611 594
EU4CQ 462 461
HS0ZFI 625 436


Callsign Total rQSOs Total rNILs % rNILs
EU4CQ 462 461 99.8
M0RTI 284 283 99.6
DK7KR 424 422 99.5
UT1PO 294 292 99.3
RK3WWA 194 192 99.0
RN4AT 806 794 98.5
F5NCU 444 435 98.0
YO7BGA 762 746 97.9
VE2DWA 132 129 97.7
PA3ADJ 611 594 97.2


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws rNILs against Ws
N4PN 38 18
K5GO 224 17
K1TTT 147 14
N6RO 286 13
W3LPL 237 12
W0AIH 135 11
K3LR 184 10
NQ4I 185 10
AA6DY 62 9
NR4M 51 9


Callsign Total rQSOs with Ws Total rNILs against Ws % rNILs against Ws
N4PN 38 18 47.4
KG4FSN 26 7 26.9
N2KPB 39 9 23.1
K2BA 33 7 21.2
N2MM 29 6 20.7
KB9YGD 30 6 20.0
K2AX 47 9 19.1
W4MYA 32 6 18.8
NR4M 51 9 17.6
AA6DY 62 9 14.5

On the basis of these tables, a closer look at N7DD's entry in the SSB contest would probably have been in order, as his rNIL rate against Ws was nearly twice that of the next station in the table. Possibly N4PN's entry in the CW contest was worthy of a closer look as well.